Skip to content

How to Choose Companies That Protect Your Privacy Online

According to the Pew Research Center, 79 percent of American adults say they are very or somewhat concerned about how companies use their data — yet most people still have no idea how many businesses are quietly collecting, packaging, and selling their personal information every single day. The companies that protect your privacy online exist precisely because this industry has grown faster than most consumers can track, and they offer real tools to push back against it.

This article breaks down the main categories of privacy-protection companies operating in 2025 and 2026 — from data broker removal services to VPN providers and encrypted communication platforms — so you can understand what each type actually does, which names lead the field in the US and UK, and how to build a protection stack that fits your actual risk level. Whether you are concerned about spam calls, identity theft, or simply being tracked around the web, there is a specific type of company built to address it.

Most guides on this topic give you a flat list of app names and call it a day. This one is different. It organizes the landscape by what these companies actually protect you from, explains the realistic limits of each approach, and gives you a clear starting point based on your priorities — not a generic “use everything” checklist that leaves you no closer to a decision.

What Data Broker Removal Companies Actually Do

Before anything else, you need to understand what data brokers are, because they sit at the center of most online privacy problems. Data brokers are companies that collect your name, address, phone number, employment history, relatives, and sometimes your health-related browsing habits — and then sell that information to marketers, insurers, background check services, and anyone else willing to pay. The data broker industry in the US operates with minimal federal regulation, a point the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has documented extensively.

Data broker removal services work by identifying where your information appears across hundreds of these sites, submitting opt-out requests on your behalf, and then monitoring those same sites to make sure your data does not quietly reappear weeks later. Without a service handling this, the manual process of finding every broker and submitting individual removal requests can take dozens of hours — and needs to be repeated regularly.

The three most tested services in this space right now are Incogni (US/UK), DeleteMe (US), and Aura (US). Incogni, built by Surfshark, covers over 420 data brokers and has had its removal claims independently verified by Deloitte — an unusual step that sets it apart from competitors who rely on self-reported numbers. DeleteMe takes a more manual approach, using real humans to handle the hardest opt-out requests, which means initial reports can take around seven days but tend to be thorough on the sites that matter most. Aura bundles data removal with identity theft insurance of up to one million dollars per member, a VPN, antivirus software, and a password manager — making it a strong option if you want fewer separate subscriptions.

Privacy Bee is worth mentioning for UK and US users who want maximum broker coverage. Its service covers over 980 data broker sites, which is among the highest available, and its browser extension blocks trackers in real time as you browse. The trade-off is price: individual plans run around $197 per year, which is notably higher than Incogni’s entry-level tier.

If you want to understand more about how these services fit into a broader privacy framework, the guide on data privacy as a service and who needs it covers the structural differences between managing privacy yourself versus outsourcing it to a specialist platform.

VPN Providers That Prioritize Privacy Over Speed

A virtual private network encrypts your internet connection and hides your IP address from websites, advertisers, and your internet service provider. This means the sites you visit cannot easily tie your activity back to your real identity or location, and your ISP cannot log your browsing history and sell it. VPNs do not remove existing data about you from broker databases — that is a separate problem — but they do limit how much new data gets collected while you browse.

NordVPN (Panama) and Proton VPN (Switzerland) are consistently rated highest among privacy-focused providers. NordVPN runs all of its servers in RAM-disk mode, meaning no data is ever written to physical storage — a design choice that makes it technically impossible to hand user records to authorities even under a court order. Proton VPN, built by the same team behind ProtonMail, routes traffic through its Secure Core infrastructure via privacy-friendly countries including Switzerland and Iceland before the connection exits to the open internet. This adds meaningful protection against network-level surveillance, especially for users traveling in countries with aggressive data monitoring.

ExpressVPN (British Virgin Islands) is a strong third option, particularly for users who want a polished interface and broad device support. It has completed 23 independent security audits as of 2025 and confirmed in its transparency report that it disclosed zero user data despite receiving over 1.38 million data requests in the second half of that year.

One limitation worth being clear about: a VPN does not make you anonymous. If you are logged into your Google or Facebook account while connected, those companies still know who you are. A VPN reduces passive tracking and hides your traffic from your ISP, but it is not a shield against every form of surveillance. For a practical breakdown of tools that address different privacy threats at once, the article on ways to protect your privacy online that actually work is a useful companion read.

Privacy-First Search Engines and Email Providers

The search engine and email provider you use by default are two of the most significant sources of ongoing data collection in your daily digital life. Google processes billions of searches each day and uses that behavioral data to build advertising profiles. Gmail scans message metadata and habits to serve targeted ads. Switching platforms in these two areas — even before adding any other tools — is one of the highest-impact privacy moves available to most people.

DuckDuckGo (US) and Startpage (Netherlands) are the most widely used privacy-focused search engines in the English-speaking world. DuckDuckGo does not track search queries or build user profiles, and its browser app for iOS and Android includes built-in tracker blocking. Startpage delivers Google search results without passing your identity to Google — a useful option for people who prefer Google’s result quality but not its data practices. Qwant, based in France, is an independent search engine compliant with EU data protection standards that does not create user profiles or sell behavioral data.

For email, ProtonMail (Switzerland) and Tuta (formerly Tutanota, Germany) both offer end-to-end encrypted email storage, meaning even the provider cannot read your messages. Tuta encrypts not just message bodies but also subject lines and calendar entries. Neither requires a phone number to register, which matters if you are trying to limit the personal information attached to new accounts you create.

Quick Note: Switching your default search engine takes about 30 seconds in any browser settings menu. It is one of the lowest-effort, highest-return privacy changes you can make today — and it has a cumulative effect, since every search you do not hand to Google is data that does not end up in your advertising profile.

Identity Theft Protection and Credit Monitoring Companies

Identity theft protection is distinct from data removal, though the two often get bundled together. The core service here is monitoring — watching your Social Security number, bank accounts, credit file, and dark web forums for signs that your information has been leaked or is being used fraudulently. According to the Federal Trade Commission, Americans reported losing over $10 billion to fraud in a recent year, with identity theft consistently ranking among the most reported complaint categories.

Aura stands out in this category because it combines dark web monitoring, credit bureau alerts across all three major agencies, and the ability to freeze your credit directly inside its app — eliminating the need to call Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion separately. LifeLock (US, owned by Gen Digital, the same parent company as Norton) is one of the longest-established brands in this space and offers up to $3 million in identity theft insurance on its highest-tier plans. In the UK, Cifas operates a protective registration service that flags your identity record at participating lenders as high-risk, making it harder for fraudsters to open credit in your name.

Our take: For most people in the US, Aura at its mid-tier plan gives you the best balance of data removal, dark web monitoring, and identity recovery support without forcing you to manage three or four separate subscriptions. If you already have a VPN you are happy with, Incogni plus a standalone identity monitoring service like LifeLock’s entry plan is a reasonable alternative that keeps costs lower.

For a broader understanding of what personal data is legally protected and what your rights are when a company misuses it, the piece on internet privacy rights and protected information is worth reading before signing up for any paid service.

Encrypted Messaging and Browser-Level Privacy Tools

Two categories of companies that often get overlooked in privacy discussions are secure messaging platforms and privacy-focused browser tools. Your text messages and phone calls — unless you are using an encrypted app — pass through your mobile carrier’s servers in a form the carrier can read and, in many countries, is legally required to store. Standard SMS is not encrypted. Neither are most default phone calls.

Signal (US, non-profit) is the most trusted encrypted messaging platform available to consumers. It uses end-to-end encryption for all messages, calls, and file transfers, and the Signal protocol itself is open-source and independently audited. WhatsApp uses the same underlying protocol for message encryption, but WhatsApp collects significant metadata — who you contact, when, and how often — which it shares with Meta. That metadata alone can reveal a great deal about your habits and relationships even without the message content.

At the browser level, the Brave browser (US) blocks ads and trackers by default without requiring any extensions or configuration. Firefox (US, Mozilla Foundation) is the most privacy-respecting mainstream browser when set up with the right extensions — uBlock Origin for ad blocking and Privacy Badger from the Electronic Frontier Foundation for tracker blocking are the two most commonly recommended additions.

For practical, specific steps you can take across your devices right now, the article on protecting your privacy online and what really works covers browser settings, app permissions, and account hygiene in concrete detail.

Quick Note: Signal is free and takes about five minutes to set up. You keep your existing phone number. The people you message do not need to do anything special — they just need Signal installed too. For UK and US users with family members abroad, Signal also eliminates international messaging costs entirely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are data removal services worth paying for, or can I do it myself?

You can do it yourself, but the time cost is significant. Most data brokers have different opt-out processes — some require a form submission, some require email requests, and some require you to prove your identity first. Even after you complete the process, your information often reappears within weeks because brokers regularly re-purchase and re-publish data. A paid service like Incogni or DeleteMe automates the initial removals and handles the ongoing monitoring, typically for $7 to $15 per month. If your time is worth anything, that math usually favors paying.

Does a VPN actually protect my privacy, or is it mostly marketing?

A VPN provides real but narrow protection. It encrypts your connection from your device to the VPN server, which prevents your internet service provider from logging your browsing history and stops basic network-level surveillance. What it does not do is protect you from the apps and websites you are logged into, stop data brokers from holding information they already have, or prevent your employer from monitoring traffic on a company network. It is a useful tool, but treating it as a complete privacy solution is a mistake.

What is the difference between identity theft protection and data removal?

Data removal services focus on taking your personal information off broker sites before it can be misused. Identity theft protection focuses on detecting misuse after it has already happened — alerting you when your Social Security number appears in a new credit application, when your bank account shows suspicious activity, or when your credentials surface on a dark web forum. The two services address different points in the same problem. Ideally, you want both, but data removal is the more proactive of the two.

Which privacy-focused companies work for both US and UK users?

Incogni, NordVPN, ProtonMail, Tuta, Signal, Brave, and Privacy Bee all offer services to both US and UK users. DeleteMe’s full service is US-focused, though it has limited international coverage. LifeLock operates primarily in the US, while Cifas protective registration is a UK-specific service. If you are based in the UK, the GDPR gives you stronger legal rights to request data deletion directly from companies — rights that do not fully apply to US residents outside California, Virginia, and a handful of other states with their own privacy laws.

Can any company guarantee my data stays off the internet permanently?

No reputable company makes that guarantee, and any that does should be treated with skepticism. Data brokers regularly acquire new data from app permissions, loyalty programs, and public records, which means your information can reappear even after being successfully removed. This is why ongoing monitoring — not a one-time removal — is the standard model for services in this space. The goal is continuous reduction of your digital footprint, not a permanent solution that requires no maintenance.

Final Thoughts

The companies that protect your privacy online are not all doing the same thing. A data broker removal service solves a different problem than a VPN, which solves a different problem than an encrypted messaging app. The most effective approach is to address the biggest vulnerability first: if your name, address, and phone number are currently listed on dozens of people-search sites, that is the highest-priority problem, and a service like Incogni or DeleteMe is the most direct way to address it. Add a reputable VPN for your day-to-day browsing, switch your email to ProtonMail or Tuta, and use Signal for sensitive conversations — and you will have addressed the majority of real-world privacy risks that affect most people.

Start with one change this week. Pick whichever service addresses the specific risk that concerns you most, spend 15 minutes setting it up, and build from there. Privacy protection is not a single product you buy — it is a set of habits and tools you layer over time.